Japan: Clichés and Stereotypes

What do you think of when you think of Japan? What words would you use to describe Japan? I’m sure most people would think of technology, Hello Kitty, sushi, and maybe geisha. They would use words like “bright”, “colourful”, “crazy”, and “strange”. I’m sure I’ve used a lot of these words and ideas, and I don’t generally have a problem with them.

Stereotypes and clichés are what they are, and they exist for a reason. Japan is bright and colourful, and does produce amazing technology and more Hello Kitty merchandise than you can shake a folding fan at. When people visit Japan for the first time, they often experience some kind of culture shock because, to the general tourist, Japan does seem to have a culture which is vastly different to that of the West.

I don’t have any problems with the stereotypes and clichés, but I do hope that people will open their eyes a little more and try to see beyond them. Today, the British media had two stories about Japan. In the Guardian, a piece by Charlie Brooker entitled “Green Kit Kats, toilets that lift the seat themselves, helpful strangers – Japan feels like another planet“:

And in the Evening Standard a piece by Emma McCarthy called “Tokyo is trending: the rise of J-Pop“:

Both articles, to my mind, did very little to depict Japan as anything other than strange and quirky. Brooker describes a visit to Japan as “akin to recovering from a serious head injury” and talks about Japan as “another planet” where the Kit Kats are green (ah, but has he seen the blue ones?) and going to the toilet is “like defecating into a robot’s mouth“.

McCarthy, on the other hand, is a little more positive but focusses mainly on the “new” J-Pop craze and how Japanese street style has “trickled into high fashion circles” with the likes of Nicki Minaj and Katy Perry leading the way (um… Gwen Stefani and Lady Gaga, anyone?).

The up-coming J-culture event, Hyper Japan, was mentioned in the Evening Standard article (although sadly without dates or website links – 24th-26th Feb, more info here). Personally, I think it’s wonderful that this event is happening and that people can learn more about how strange and quirky Japan is, or how mad the music and fashion are. But I hope that the people who attend Hyper Japan also take the time to sample some exquisite sushi at the Sushi Awards 2012, check out some classic artwork at the Japanese Gallery stall, or talk to some tour operators (like Inside Japan Tours) about what visiting Japan is really like. Last year there were even chances to experience martial arts, calligraphy and the tea ceremony.

I realise that, actually, martial arts, calligraphy and tea ceremony are as much stereotypes of Japan as Hello Kitty, but what I’m saying is that I hope people realise there is more than modern pop culture in Japan, and that actually it’s a country with an interesting history and a vast culture which includes not only the bright, colourful trends of today, but also the bright, colourful trends of the past (just look at kimonos – not exactly dull, are they?).

Charlie Brooker says he’s in Japan “to write some travel pieces for [the Guardian], which will appear later in the year“. Let’s hope he stops watching the TV, gets out of his hotel room, and experiences some of the other side of what Japan has to offer.

10 thoughts on “Japan: Clichés and Stereotypes

  1. Here here. As you may remember I had culture shock combined with jet lag on my first day in Japan but after that I loved the country and its people. I hope Charlie Booker gets to see the real Japan ;0)

    Like

  2. The Charlie Brooker article really annoyed and disappointed me – especially when he said in five years he imagines a toilet will play him a lullaby when he uses it. If that’s the case, Japan is the future already as I’ve used toilets there that play tunes! Okay, so that’s a bit tongue in cheek but it was a rubbish article which didn’t encourage me to read more of his work. I don’t think he even explained the kitkats were green tea flavoured, not green just because they fancy it.

    Like

  3. In my country, one thing I hate when they stereotype Japan is that they only think of the country as a place for anime and perversion. I am a fan of this all-girl Jrock band SCANDAL, one time there was a discussion of fans who wished they were famous here, but then some fans said they will just be disrespected that instead of seeing their skills as musicians they will only be seen as girls full of sex appeal.
    I also met people in japanese culture events who only attend to get pictures of girls in cosplay and are not actually interested in learning more about japanese culture. sad.

    Like

      • Although most cosplays are anime related. There are other things to learn about anime aside from the story and the cool characters. People find it weird why anime chars have spiky hair, or why japan likes robots. But they didn’t know that robots and spiky hair tells a lot about Japanese tradition.

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s