Book Review: Tokyo Hearts by Renae Lucas-Hall

Sometimes I like nothing better than to curl up on the sofa in my jogging bottoms and read, don’t you? I was in just that kind of mood on Sunday, so I sat down to read Tokyo Hearts by Renae Lucas-Hall. Somehow time got away with me and , without intending to, I managed to finish reading it in a day, but at just under 200 pages that wasn’t too surprising.

Tokyo Hearts is a love story about sweet, stylish Haruka and university student Takashi. The young Japanese couple enjoy a platonic relationship, meeting up in a cafe once a week, but Takashi dreams of more; that is, until Haruka’s rich ex-boyfriend comes back on the scene.

This is a sweet, chick-lit kind of story that shouldn’t be taken too seriously. I think you’d need to be a bit of a Japanophile to want to read it (and to understand some of the cultural references), but if you were too much of a purist you probably wouldn’t like it. I tried to read it for what it was – an entertaining story – without being too snobby.

Renae clearly knows the places she talks about, including tiny details such as train station platform numbers to make the story come to life, but at times this felt a little forced. In the back of my mind the whole time I couldn’t help thinking “this is a story about Japanese people written by an Australian born Brit, and something isn’t quite right”, but I don’t know if that was just because I knew. If I had read the story without knowing about the author, I wonder if I would have known it wasn’t written by a Japanese author? It shouldn’t matter, of course, but I felt a slight lack of authenticity, which I don’t feel when I read translations of Japanese novels, or indeed some other novels by non-Japanese authors.

I don’t mean to be overly critical though – Tokyo Hearts is a nice story, and makes for a good way to pass a Sunday afternoon. It’s what my mum and I would call a “bath book” (i.e. something you can read in the bath without worrying if the pages get wet). It’s not a classic, but I don’t think it’s trying to be. For the few hours I was reading I was entirely transported to Japan and, having visited a lot of the places described, was able to really visualise the story and feel like I was in Japan.

The awkward romance in the story seemed typical of what I know of young Japanese people’s behaviour (and their parents’), and other elements (such as Haruka’s neighbour’s frantic dieting) also seemed to reflect real life in Japan today. I felt the story was a little weaker when it came to describing life as a Japanese teacher inside an English conversation school, but perhaps my perception of this is wrong, as it is of course based only on what I observed in two schools.

Overall, Tokyo Hearts is more mind-softening than mind-blowing, but sometimes that’s what I want from a book. After all, three of my all-time favourite books are probably classed as chick-lit: Bridget Jones’s Diary, Sex and the City and Eat Pray Love. I can’t be too precious about books – stories should entertain the reader, and sometimes that’s enough.

If my words don’t persuade you to give it a chance, perhaps charity will – 10% of the author’s profits from the sale of the paperback of Tokyo Hearts in 2012/13 will be donated to the Japan Society Tohoku Earthquake Relief Fund.

Visit Renae Lucas-Hall’s website ( for more information or to purchase a copy of the book (also available from Amazon). You can also read a sample chapter on her website, and find out more about the sequel, Tokyo Dreams, due out in 2014.

3 thoughts on “Book Review: Tokyo Hearts by Renae Lucas-Hall

  1. I think I’ll give it a go, sounds like a nice, fun read. However, as a confirmed orientaphile who has mainly read books about China and Tibet I’d love to get a recommendation from you of a really good Japanese novel (any genre, but I do like true life stories and historical fiction best). Thanks 🙂


    • Hi Liz, I know it has been a couple of years since you posted your comment but I haven’t visited this site for a long time. I wanted to thank you for deciding to give my book a go. In regards to the authenticity in this book, I can assure you I have the proper credentials to write a book about Japan and the Japanese culture. I completed a major in Japanese language as well as Japanese literature and culture at university. I lived in Tokyo for several years, I have worked with Japanese people for over twenty years and I’ve been to Japan six times. I really hope you enjoyed reading my book and I would recommend Jun’ichirō Tanizaki and Yukio Mishima f you are looking for Japanese authors who write wonderful books set in Japan.


Leave a Reply to Haikugirl Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s